Bay Island Homes For Sale

Search homes in Bay Island Siesta Key

Search Bay Island homes for sale or start browsing all Siesta Key homes for sale. The Bay Island subdivision is one of the largest real estate developments on Siesta Key. If you are looking for a house, and not a condo, this is definitely the place to look. The Bay Island community is surrounded on all sides by water, making it an idyllic little island community. The waterfront homes offer stunning views of the Sarasota Bay, the Sarasota city skyline, and the beautiful Ringling Bridge.

Bay Island has 169 homes varying from small beach bungalows to traditionally sized homes to impressive waterfront mansions. You can find homes with anything from 800 to 8000 square feet of living space; whatever your space needs may be, there is something here for you. These attractive homes range in price from the $400,000's all the way up to $15,000,000.

See all Bay Island homes for sale below or learn more about Bay Island real estate, and the amenities that make this such a great place to live in Sarasota.

Search Bay Island Siesta Key Homes For Sale

All Listings Over $1,000,000
1 – 3 of 3 Listings
Price, High to Low

6 Bed • 7 Bath • 6,436 Sf


901 Norsota Way, Sarasota

Showstopping Sarasota Bay And Downtown City Skyline Views From The Best Vantage In Sarasota! Walls Of Windows Towering 24 Ft High Greet You Upon En...

View Listing
View Listing
Reduced 5%

6 Bed • 4 Bath • 4,434 Sf


746 Siesta Dr, Sarasota

Experience Exceptional Waterfront Living And The Island Lifestyle On The Coveted Northern Tip Of Siesta Key, The Choice For Serious Boaters Who Val...

View Listing

4 Bed • 4 Bath • 3,342 Sf


657 Siesta Dr, Sarasota

•*´¨`*•siesta Key Legal Weekly Rental•*´¨`*•*•.¸¸.•2017 Built Rob Allegra Kristi Model*•.¸¸.•delight In The Convenience To Downtown And Beyond From...

View Listing


Living in Bay Island Siesta Key

Bay Island residents can take full advantage of all that Siesta Key has to offer. Siesta Key is a tropical paradise that boasts one of the finest beaches in the country, with world-famous sunsets. Siesta Key Beach is a picture perfect stretch of sugary white sand and turquoise waves. Beach lovers will also enjoy the facilities offered at Siesta Beach, including volleyball and tennis courts, picnic areas, and concession stands. Bay Island residents are also in close proximity to the city of Sarasota, which offers a multitude of shopping, dining, and entertainment options.

Contact Us About Bay Island Siesta Key Homes For Sale

You couldn’t ask for more than what Bay Island offers: an elegant waterfront home, located near both a beautiful tropical beach and a bustling city full of culture and entertainment. Bay Island is just what you’ve been waiting for. Contact me for help to find your dream home.

Not seeing anything you like? Start searching other Siesta Key homes & condos for sale or call me at (941) 954-9400 for help finding your new dream home on Siesta Key in Sarasota FL!

All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; availability of any listing should always be independently verified.

Listing information is provided for consumer personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law.

Listing data comes from My Florida Regional MLS.

Listing information last updated on June 3rd, 2020 at 12:15pm CDT.

Have a Question?

Contact Us

Follow Us