4 Reasons to Love Casey Key, FL: Casey Key Rentals & Real Estate

Posted by Tamara Berryman on Monday, June 2nd, 2014 at 2:22pm.

If you're searching for beachfront real estate, Casey Key, FL is one of Sarasota's best kept secrets. This barrier island located right next to Nokomis takes advantage of its long and narrow shape which translates into some stunning panoramic views of Blackburn Bay and the Gulf of Mexico. Home to breathtaking scenery, sugar-white sand beaches, multi-million dollar beachfront homes, and plenty of attractive amenities, it's no surprise why Casey Key rentals are so popular.

There's a lot more to Casey Key, FL other than exquisite real estate however. We list our top 4 reasons why this paradise may be the ideal location for a vacation home.

Private, Scenic Surroundings

Casey Key real estate sits on an 8-mile stretch of which is only accessible by a single road lined with hibiscus trees and lush green landscaping. Since the area is predominantly residential, you can expect quiet streets void of the usual throngs of tourists which dominate the Sarasota metro area. There are no high-rise condos buildings, hotel chains or tourist traps to be found; it's one of the last places you can find that "Old Florida" charm.

Casey Key has 600 full-time and part-time residents including celebrities like novelist Stephen King, former talk show host Rosie O'Donnell, and tennis star Martina Navratilova. Private beaches offer a relaxing respite, and close encounters with local fauna.

Gulf to Bay Homes

Have you dreamed of ever having an Intracoastal or Gulf views from your home? Many Casey Key homes for sale offer both! Admire gorgeous sunsets from your private beach access on the Gulf of Mexico on the western side, and enjoy deep water boat access via the Intracoastal from the eastern side. You really can have the best of both worlds living on Casey Key. A terrific choice for yachters and fishing enthusiasts alike.

1 – 6 of 39 Listings
Price, High to Low
View Listing
Reduced 3%

4 Bed • 6 Bath • 6,472 Sf • 1 Acres


602 S Casey Key Rd, Nokomis

Own Your Gulf-front Masterpiece Today. This "castle By The Sea" Has Been Extensively Remodeled And Reinvigorated In 2017 And 2018. Every Surface,...

View Listing

5 Bed • 7 Bath • 5,335 Sf • 1 Acres


2905 Casey Key Rd, Nokomis

Brand New Beach House - Certificate Of Occupancy Issued 2/3/20. Opportunities Such As This Do Not Come Along Often. You May Find New Construction...

View Listing
View Listing
Reduced 5%

4 Bed • 6 Bath • 6,767 Sf • 1 Acres


1906 Casey Key Rd, Nokomis

Now Is The Opportunity To Purchase This Rare Beach And Bayfront Estate Sized Property On Casey Key. Amenities Include Private Beach With Cabana, B...

View Listing

4 Bed • 5 Bath • 4,496 Sf • 1 Acres


502 S Casey Key Rd, Nokomis

Your Own Slice Of Paradise Awaits You. Enjoy Gulf Breezes And The Sound Of Waves Lapping The Shore In This Magnificent Gated Key West Style Home. T...

View Listing

6 Bed • 5 Bath • 3,983 Sf


412 S Casey Key Rd, Nokomis

This Spectacular One Of A Kind Property On Casey Key Awaits. Wake Up Every Morning To Beautiful Gulf Of Mexico Views From Your Third Floor Master S...

View Listing

7 Bed • 7 Bath • 6,363 Sf • 1 Acres


430 Casey Key Rd, Nokomis

A Boater's Paradise! This Gated Private Estate Features A Main House, Guest Cottage, Additional Empty Lot And Deeded Private Beach Access. Complet...

View Listing

Amenities Galore

Due to strict zoning, there is only one dining option on the island itself: Casey Key Fish House. This relaxed atmosphere offers great waterfront dining and a tiki bar. Not to worry though as there are plenty of restaurants in Nokomis, just across the bridge. Two public beach access points can be found in North Jetty Park Beach and Nokomis beach.

When you feel like branching out, downtown Sarasota is only 15 miles away. Nature buffs can get their fill in Spanish Park in the nearby community of Osprey, FL. Some of the highlights include pioneer-era buildings, nature trails and a butterfly garden.

North Jetty Park Beach

For endless recreation, North Jetty Park Beach is a local favorite offering amenities and scenic sights without having to step foot off of Casey Key, FL. Try your hand at fishing and surfing or spend hours bird watching or admiring the boats meandering in the waters. Amenities include picnic shelters and tables, outdoor showers, a sand volleyball court, concession stands, a playground and a bait shop.

Interested in learning more about Casey Key real estate near Sarasota Florida? Contact Tamara Berryman for a free consultation or to arrange a showing.

Tamara Berryman

Leave a Comment

All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; availability of any listing should always be independently verified.

Listing information is provided for consumer personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law.

Listing data comes from My Florida Regional MLS.

Listing information last updated on May 26th, 2020 at 2:45am CDT.

Have a Question?

Contact Us

Follow Us