Oyster Bay Estates Homes For Sale

A historical neighborhood located on the Roberts Bay section of Sarasota Bay, Oyster Bay Estates offers an eclectic range of homes in an exclusive and beautiful section of Sarasota. While most of the original homes in the area were taken down in order to make room for condominium complexes and newer homes, the neighborhood still has the quaint “Old Florida” charm that makes it popular with today’s homeowners.

From your home in Oyster Bay Estates, Sarasota, you will be able to experience great views of the Bay as well as Siesta Key, a white-sand key that is just across the water. If you want to sink your toes in the sand, Siesta Key Beach is just a short drive away. You will also be just minutes away from downtown Sarasota, where you can take advantage of all that the city has to offer, from cultural events to restaurants, boutiques to shopping malls, art galleries to opera. In this way, you receive the best of both worlds: a tropical oasis near enough to the tourist areas and downtown sections of Sarasota and the neighboring keys, but far enough to be out of the traffic, noise and hustle and bustle that go along with any city. Read more about Oyster Bay Estates amenities.

Oyster Bay Estates Homes For Sale in Sarasota, FL

All Listings $500,000 - $600,000 $900,000 - $1,000,000
Over $1,000,000
1 – 6 of 9 Listings
Price, High to Low

4 Bed • 6 Bath • 5,889 Sf

$4,650,000

1441 Rebecca Ln, Sarasota

Inspired Coastal Design. Located In The Private Gated Enclave Of Oyster Bay Landings, This Amazing Waterfront Residence Combines Unique Architectur...

View Listing
View Listing
Reduced 3%

4 Bed • 5 Bath • 4,783 Sf

$2,995,000

1522 N Lake Shore Dr, Sarasota

Tucked Away On Lakeshore Drive In A Storybook Lakefront Setting, This Exquisite Estate Embodies Tropical Elegance And Style. Luxurious Appointments...

View Listing
View Listing
Reduced 4%

5 Bed • 5 Bath • 5,043 Sf

$2,250,000

1207 N Lake Shore Dr, Sarasota

The Motivated Owner Has Positioned This Property To Be One Of The Best Waterfront Opportunities In The Marketplace Today. Located On A Boat Basin I...

View Listing
View Listing
Reduced 8%

3 Bed • 6 Bath • 5,968 Sf

$2,250,000

1818 N Lake Shore Dr, Sarasota

Set In Oyster Bay Estates And Remarkable In Every Way Is Villa Lidia, A Stunning Example Of Architectural Mastery And Creatively Imagined By Acclai...

View Listing
View Listing
Reduced 7%

3 Bed • 4 Bath • 3,003 Sf • 1 Acres

$2,150,000

1313 S Lake Shore Dr, Sarasota

Mid-century Modern, Canal-front Home On Over 1/2 Acre In Desirable Oyster Bay Estates. Easy Access To Roberts Bay/intracoastal. Partial Westerly V...

View Listing

5 Bed • 6 Bath • 6,963 Sf

$2,100,000

1145 N Lake Shore Dr, Sarasota

Due To Covid 19, This Home May Not Be Shown Until June 1. Seller Has Priced Aggressively At Land Value For Immediate Sale. Located In Oyster Bay, O...

View Listing

Want to Learn More About Real Estate In Sarasota?

Tamara Berryman can help you find your dream home in Sarasota, Florida.
Call 941.954.0900 or contact Tamara online for a free consultation.

Contact Tamara

Oyster Bay Estates Homes For Sale

Oyster Bay Estates real estate ranges from modest ranches to large Key West-inspired estates. Since these are coveted properties, they do not go up for sale often. If you have your heart set on living in this gorgeous neighborhood, please contact me promptly so that we can schedule a showing of any available properties.

Amenities that you will enjoy while living in Oyster Bay include:

  • Deepwater canals, so you can keep your boat at your residence.
  • Spectacular sunset and Bay views.
  • Close proximity to Siesta Key Beach, rated the #1 beach in the world in 2011.
  • Easy access to downtown Sarasota.
  • An excellent school district.
  • Excellent medical care facilities nearby.

Back to Communities

All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; availability of any listing should always be independently verified.

Listing information is provided for consumer personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law.

Listing data comes from My Florida Regional MLS.

Listing information last updated on May 31st, 2020 at 11:15pm CDT.

Have a Question?

Contact Us

Follow Us